Here's a talk I wrote in a huge hurry which I gave last night at the launch of the Poneke Black pages, a directory of activist groups in the Wellington region. The organisers asked me to talk on how I sustain my activism.
I've been asked to talk about how I sustain my activism, and in thinking about this in the days before I am to talk I have to suppress a great wave of panic, that I am in fact not sustaining it, that I haven't sustained it, that I am unconfident that if I am keeping up with anything that constitutes activism that I can continue to keep it up. That quite often I feel fed up, and exhausted and misunderstood and underachieving and a bit useless and sad about being an activist. And I don't think that's all that sustainable.
But after all here I am 36, and still getting grumpy and inspired and upset and occasionally joyful about working for change with other people. That for my whole adult life I've never quite, despite a few feeble attempts, been able to abandon, a wild belief that what I call activism is worth doing. And not for a moment do I think 36 is very old, but I recognise it is old for this particular group of people.
I think there have been some things or some ideas that have helped me keep engaging with working for change. And if I'm not actively working for change then I'm actively thinking about why I'm not, and thinking about what activism or working for change is and isn't.
For me, and I recognise this is probably entirely specific to me, and perhaps utterly un-useful and irrelevant and possibly dull for all of you, but you did ask, for me there' been a few epiphanies that have really helped.
I think they're related points. But given the time, I figure that rather than presenting a well-crafted speech that ties all the following points together with appropriate moving anecdotes, smooth and lyrical transitions and tops it off with a snappy ending, in a good proper empowering and anarchic way. I'm going to allow you to work out the connections
One was in realising that working for change was an actual active and deliberate choice on my part. That I wanted it. That the stories that I told myself for a while that I had to do it because no-one else would, or because the issues were so urgent and important that I was forced to act, that the work needed me, that I had A Calling, were quite attractive and liberating and exciting and empowering on one hand, but quite damaging on the other. . If I have to do something then I'll put up with a whole lot of conditions to do with it. I'll be the martyr that sits through countless pointless meetings, I'll suffer dodgy decisions, and doubtful decision-making. I'll tolerate put-downs and personal attacks, and attempts to undermine me from supposed allies, because the work is Very Important and Very Necessary.
But If I do that same work out of choice then things change. I'm going to make the work and my involvement in it as pleasurable and meaningful and as possible. I know I can leave, So I make sure that things are in place to make the work worthwhile and fun and sustainable, And that I achieve some of the things that I want to. And I work with people who support and nurture and respect me as well as challenging and irritating me.
My next epiphany was in realising that the distinction between activists and non-activists can be a bit pompous. And I'm not saying that we shouldn't be proud of the work that we do do, but that I don't think it's useful or sustainable to decide that there's us who care about the world and do stuff, and them who don't care and do nothing. I have a basic assumption that most people give a shit. And that most people, if they could, would be doing work that means something to them, and that helps them make a world more enjoyable to live in. that my life has turned out that I can be very explicit in working for change is a reflection not of my moral superiority, but of a privileged position I hold in society. I've been able to make some decisions in my life that allow me to do the sort of work that I want. At times I've been able to be living okay off a benefit and organise stuff that means something to me. That I've had the ability to actively choose the sort of relationships I have with my partner and my friends, and to choose when I had my daughter. There are a lot of people cleaning loos, and donning suits, who've got demands on them I can't possibly dream of. A lot of people who would like to be working for change in the ways I sometime have been able to.
There are also a lot of people working for change in ways I can't possibly imagine. On their Marae, or the way they're bringing up their kids, or the way they support their friend in leaving an abusive marriage, I believe the network of people working for change is large and significant and for me I find that moving and that makes me feel that there is a support network much wider than the group at 128, or those listed in this directory.
I had another epiphany (it's a particular hobby of mine) when my friend Marie in Dunedin said to me Pakeha culture is in crisis. Suddenly I understood something that had been bugging me. It's related to this idea that I'd heard for a while about the distinction between power and privilege. Yes, Pakeha, and particularly the sort of Pakeha family I come from, are privileged. But I've spent an awful lot of time among Pakeha middle class who have a lot of privilege but sure don't feel powerful. They feel helpless, and disempowered and guilty as hell. And quite a lot of my friends in this position have done activism, or are doing it. It's twelve past six as I'm writing so I'll try to get to my point. And lots of my Pakeha friends have got to the point of realising they need something to sustain themselves in their work for change, or in their lives, or to hand on to any semblance of mental health, And I think this understanding that we need to sustain ourselves is general and crosses cultures and some Maori, and I realize that it has not come to easy to them, have been able to find in their culture some tools and some support mechanisms still in tact despite the ravages of colonisation. That some Maori, when looking for the things they need to sustain them, have a place to go. And I think what Marie was saying was that for all the privileges that Pakeha like me hold in this society, for all the dishonour and dishonesty and nastiness done in our name, when we're looking for a place to go to sustain us, we can't find it. Pakeha who want to live in a society based on principles of choice and respect and community are lost and are in crisis. In no way am I trying to minimise the incredible challenges for Maori, and other non-Pakeha, and I'm not ignoring the fact that many Maori are a long way from being able to access their culture and its associated support. But for me I agree Pakeha culture is in crisis. And for me working for change is my response to that crisis. That in working for change with other people, I am looking not to reform society for other people but for myself. I want desperately a community based on values of respect and freedom, and I want methods of accountability, and people to support me in political and other work and craft and ambitions and relationships that I work for. And as a Pakeha, I have quite a lot of work to do to start establishing the sort of society I want to be part of.
Perhaps my final epiphany, (it's now 6.34) so let's say the final and most important epiphany, well maybe it's not an epiphany, but a slow growing realisation, is that really, deep down, I'm quite a decent person. And this sense of decency, a sense of self-worth is I think crucial to sustaining myself as someone who likes to do stuff. And I do worry that there seems to be a bit of an element of self-hate among a lot of people who probably define themselves as activists. And I think self-hate is incredibly sad and incredibly damaging to people being sustained in any movement for change. Of course it is understandable. We do live in a society that encourages it. Or that leads to it.
But I think if we are working for change because of a basic sense that we are deep down bad and indecent people then the movement we are involved in is bound to suffer. I worry about people realising their own inner lack of self-worth also assume that other people are similarly deep down bad and worthless. And so we set traps for each other trying to catch each other out, trying to trip each other up and so ha we can say, just as we thought, not only do you like mainstream music, you're George Bush's love child, Ha, not only do you eat meat, you are personally responsible for the destruction of Amazon rainforest equivalent to 2 and a half rugby fields and that was just last Thursday. You mispronounced the word Maori, it was you wasn't it? You signed the seabed and foreshore policy.
I think I have been able to sustain myself to the extent that I have because of friends I've made through working for change. And for basic nurturing, and respect and honouring by the other people that the work I do is important and that my motives are good. And when I don't get that sense any more, and I don't find the gems of people that nourish and nurture me in the work I do, and when the accusations or presumptions or blame or hostility, either personal or general in any community I work in, outweigh the fun and the love and the friendship then I don't stand a chance and I don't fancy anyone else's either.
So I think I'm all epiphanied out now.